You’ve seen these types of charts before, almost always with the implied joke of “bad breath”, where the number of stocks outperforming is a small fraction.
They are good reminders that most stocks are poor performers. Active management; trying to pick say the top 30 names out of 200 (effectively saying 170 of them are going to do less than the benchmark), is a difficult game at the best of times.

The above graph averages out towards 40%, which is still way higher than the number I usually see quoted, in which it’s really only the top 10-20% of stocks that drive the benchmark. The current number had been close to 7 (FANGMAN-esque stocks, described as the “magnificent 7”). Not 7%, just 7.
So why do we do it?
Well, actually, for the most part we don’t. We usually run somewhere between 50-70% of the fund as a core (low cost, ease of implementation passive vehicles) satellite (where the active tilts come in, and the active managers) approach.
Sometimes even those active tilts are still using passive vehicles (e.g., a DAA decision to overweight Japan, or Europe, or the Emerging markets, via products like the IJP, IEU, or IEM).
For the rest that we do (in terms of active management) it is, in our view, sometimes the case that the benchmark doesn’t adequately show you the real risk you are taking.
For example, for the most part, the ASX 200 is banks + resources. Now if Australia doesn’t have a recession (26 years and counting!) and if China doesn’t have a hiccup (stronger for longer!) then the ASX will likely keep doing well.
However, if Australia does have a recession (for whatever reason, the exact “why” is not the point here), and if China does have a hiccup (for whatever reason, the exact “why” is not the point here), then a benchmark that is mostly banks and resources won’t do well.
So, did the benchmark, in this case, give you a well-diversified all-weather core exposure to the underlying asset class. Or, did it take a big bet on 2 very specific themes (“housing, and holes”, as it is usually termed).
So yes, sometimes you have a good basis for thinking “I can try to smooth out some of those possible risks, by including more of the other sectors”.
And if the big threat never comes to pass, it will look like you wasted your time. But that’s a bit like thinking “if the house never burns down I wasted all those insurance premiums”.
Important Information: This document has been prepared by Aequitas Investment Partners Pty Ltd ABN 92 644 165 266 (“Aequitas”, “our”, “we”), a Corporate Authorised Representative (no. 1284389) of AIP FS Pty Ltd ABN 49 680 982 478 (Australian Financial Services Licensee no. 700016) and is for distribution within Australia to wholesale clients only.
This document is based on information available at the time of publishing, information which we believe is correct and any opinions, conclusions or forecasts are reasonably held or made as at the time of its compilation, but no warranty is made as to its accuracy, reliability or completeness. To the extent permitted by law, neither Aequitas nor any of its affiliates accept liability to any person for loss or damage arising from the use of the information herein.
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
General Advice Warning: This document has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and therefore you should consider its appropriateness, having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs. Before making any decision about whether to acquire a financial product, you should obtain and read the relevant Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) or Investor Directed Portfolio Service Guide (IDPS Guide) and consider talking to a financial adviser.
Taxation warning: Aequitas is not authorised to provide tax (financial) advice and is not a registered tax agent. Investors should seek their own tax advice from a registered tax agent or a registered tax (financial) adviser if they intend to rely on this information to satisfy the liabilities or obligations or claim entitlements that arise, or could arise, under a taxation law. We recommend that you consult a registered tax agent or a tax specialist to confirm your taxation position.